Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Out of the Blue

















I know it seems crazy to start posting to this blog in the middle (more like the end) of the semester but it seems like a good way to keep track of what I'm working on right now. I'm trying to figure out a way to create my building in Digital Project, so that I have flexible dimensions and angles.
My goal is to create a complex for ecological research that varies across the length of the project. Toward the city side, the complex would be more based on a cartesian grid. Toward the river side, the architecture would become more irregular. I haven't completely figured out what the rule system for that part of the complex would be yet, but I hope working in Digital project will help.


Friday, December 18, 2009

Final Reviews

An Introspective Learning Community

Site Analysis

We began by studying our site at the corner of Wabash and Van Buren in the heart of the South Loop of Chicago. We analyzed the shadow and light on our site by building a model in Digital Project that treated the shadows as three-dimensional forms. We studied the conditions during the school day on the summer and winter solstice in order to understand the extremes of light and shadow on our site. Through this analysis we realized that light is especially scarce during the morning and afternoon. We cut plans and sections of our shadow model to understand the varying qualities of light across the site. This allowed us to place program according to the light requirements of each program type. For example, we placed the auditorium on the west side of the site because it is the darkest location due to the shadows of the CNA building and the other taller buildings surrounding our site. We placed the gym on the north side of the site, because this is also a location which does not receive much light. We felt it was important for the art, science and music rooms to have indirect northern light so these are located at the north side of the south building. The dining hall is on the east side in order to receive diffused light.

Four Buildings, One School
We designed our school as four separate buildings to recreate the urban environment on a smaller, more manageable scale. As a result our building educates students on how to live in the city. Students are required to travel vertically within each building, similar to the way a city requires its inhabitants to reach interior spaces. Four buildings surround a central atrium which serves as the playground and a place for all of the students to interact. We considered a day in the life of a sixth grader as a way to present the various other students a child might encounter during the school day. In the morning, all of the students enter the ground level circulation space and filter up into their respective buildings and their individual classrooms. Here in the community circulation space all of the grades cross paths with one another. Upon entering his school, the sixth grader might encounter 5th, 7th, and 8th graders. Around noon, he would leave his sixth grade classroom to eat lunch in the dining hall with 6th, 7th and 8th graders. Then he would attend recess in the courtyard with 5th and 6th graders. Then they would travel back to their classrooms and later exit the school through the ground floor circulation at the end of the day, again having the opportunity to interact with all grade levels.

Unifying through Form
The atrium of our building encloses the learning community and physically connects all four buildings. The form of our atrium reflects our experiments in fluidity and part to whole relationship of the individual buildings and the school. We used digital project as a tool to create flexible connections and a more fluid overall form. The atrium also shows our ideas about light by flattening toward the south end to receive more light and folding more on the north end; reaching up for light.

Responding to Light Conditions
Our design uses height differences to optimize the quality and quantity of light according to program needs. The north building is the tallest to reach up for light since this an area with dense shadows. The south building is the lowest in order to receive light without shading the rest of the building. We based the heights of the east and west buildings on our shadow analysis, so the west building is taller to extend past the shadows of the CNA building. We used curves to create an even distribution of quantity and quality of light throughout the day in the classrooms. This way we were able to treat the classrooms equally with regard to light. The terraces line up on the north side and peel away at rotating angles to bring more light into the classrooms and open up the middle of the building. These terraces provide opportunities for skylights at the top of the terraces and possible occupiable spaces adjoining the classrooms.

Early Study Models
We experimented with rhino in order to find ways our building could step back for light and achieve terracing without using rectangular blocks. These studies helped us understand the sheer volume of program. Next we explored a diagrammatic method of creating four buildings and a central courtyard by using cones in digital project. These cones were guided by several sketches of overlapping circles. We used curve commands in digital project to connect these cones fluidly into one form. Although the circles did not provide opportunities for quality program spaces, we decided to use a larger radius for the curves. In Rhino we constructed terraces and filled the interior of the classroom bands with shared program. We also capped each building with shared program. We created further study models using horizontal circulation before deciding that this method of circulation would not be very useful or economical. Our work culminated with an urban inspired model using vertical circulation to mimic the movement within the city.

Response 1
-The interior courtyards in our project were under appreciated. Vivian pointed out that capping them with shared program blocks light from these courtyards.
-We don't have to engage the building to the north of our site.
- We should engage the "L", although Danielle and I wanted to use the circulation as a buffer from the "L". We discussed the idea of switching the stairs from level to level.
- Create "erasable" boundaries of shared program on the ground floor.
-Consider reflected light, and re-analyze the light within our building as we initally analyzed the light on our site.
-Glen mentioned that we should have an entry level to playground connection.
-We could work in section more, for example allow the space overlooking the gym to be opened up.
-Show how lively the atrium is.
-Work on designing the courtyard space.
-Level 0 is very dark, perhaps pierce the courtyard to allow light to enter this circulation space.
-Inhabit the atrium skin.

Response 2
-Can form change the program?
-Make the schools respond to the atrium. What is the interaction in this space? The void should be at a human scale.
-Could the building have connections across the atrium for a more spatial experience and allow the children to explore. Appeal to the children's curiosity. Danielle and I avoided this because we felt that it would create a mall-like feel within the building which we thought didn't fit well with the goals of our school.
-Reconsider the unprogrammed collective spaces
-Auditorium could take advantage of terracing
-Re-engage the city
-Design the courtyard space, allow it to influence the form of the classrooms.
-There needs to be a better reason for raising the atrium up one level above the ground.
-We discussed both the "gold" digital project model and our current design. I agreed with Craig's comments that although we like the aesthetic of the gold model, there are no classrooms in it and there are problems with it that don't exist in our current model. He said that the gold model is not necessarily a better building. The current design has positive qualities that are not in the gold model, for example the interior courtyards within the east and west buildings. We felt that we can't really compare our building to the gold model since it is only a diagramatic study and its geometry did not work in plan.

Monday, December 14, 2009

Sunday, December 13, 2009

Here is an attempt to come up with a way to physically build the atrium surface using straight pieces of basswood (1.5' thick).
Today we met with Karl and decided to use thinner basswood sticks to build the frame. This method would allow us use long pieces of basswood running the length of our building. Thinner basswood allows us to bend it in both plan and section.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Working on the Atrium and Connecting Surface

In class today we talked about our ideas for the wood model we have been building. We decided to use basswood for the atrium and connecting surface on our building rather than a wire framework. I tried using curves in Rhino to create a folding surface between the buildings. Seems like there are a lot of possibilities for what this surface could look like, so we plan on spending more time experimenting with our ideas in both digital project and Rhino.
Here is a view within the atrium (looking Northwest from the playground area). The folding surface creates some interesting visual lines in the ceiling.

Added walls to complete level 0. Next step - add the atrium roof and connect curve surface.

Sunday, December 6, 2009

Terraces Model in Digital Project

Added stairs, courtyard, faculty entrance and small courtyards within the east and west schools.

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Digital Project Model and Plans

Whahoo! Finally we have a digital project model like our terraces from Rhino! We hope to use parameters to explore various ceiling height options and the experiment with the width of the terraces. We need to figure out how to import more curves either from AutoCAD or rhino so that we can add the stairways to this model. Then we plan to experiment with connect curve in order to create the exciting new surface that encloses our four schools into one building and covers the atrium.

We've been working out a lot of the details in plan as well, including stairways, elevators, storage, classrooms, and stairways. Today in class we discussed several things we plan to work on.
1. Difference in thickness of walls. For example, the glass walls of the classrooms facing the courtyard should be 6" thick, where the walls between the classrooms should be 1' thick. This would help our plans read from a greater distance.
2. Thickness of hallways can vary along their length - this would allow the classrooms to become more rectangluar making it easier to add entrances
3. Shared Program connections - we have no clear solution for this currently. Karl suggested an interesting proposal for connecting the shared program which involves branching out the program between the schools.
During our pinup on Tuesday, we discussed the layout of our plans for the final review. We would like to add tone to the plans in order to distinguish larger programatic elements from circulation. We also considered printing each plan on a separate sheet and creating a section that relates to each plan.

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

In Pursuit of the "Gold" Model


Our current goal is to combine our terraced rhino model and our digital project model. We have a pretty good idea of how the program will fit in the site and where the different spaces will be located. We feel that the digital project surface we created in our cone model would be a good way to tie the four schools together into one building and create a more intriguing exterior envelope. We're hoping that the combination of these forms will result in a school where outsiders have one understanding of the building, yet once you enter the building you have a different understanding of the relationship between the four schools.
We are working on re-building our terraces in digital project by exporting the curves from rhino so that we can draw over them. We are interested in using parameters to experiment with varying terrace width and the width of the corridors. Digital Project will also allow us to experiment with the differences in ceiling height of the shared program.

Monday, November 23, 2009

Stairs






Level 4


Level 3

Level 2

Level 1

Level 0

Thursday, November 19, 2009







On Tuesday, we discussed our project further and considered possibilities that would free up space for our courtyard. We decided to reorganize our school so that we would have 4 separate schools each with their own stairways. This would allow us to remove the ramps connecting the classrooms. We would connect all four of the shared program spaces which cap each school. Another idea we explored was to have the walls of each floor line up at the north side. The terraces would then gather sunlight from the south. A covered atrium would also reduce energy use in our building because the courtyard would not be mechanically conditioned but would take advantage of solar heat gain.

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Courtyards Influence Form




In these studies, I tried to explore ways that the courtyards could have an equal influence on the form of the building. There are three conditions in this model: 1. Courtyard cone is tangent to the classroom cone, 2. courtyard cone carves away classroom cone, or 3. courtyard is carved by the classrooms. One problem with these studies is that they still have residual spaces between the courtyard and the classrooms. Perhaps these areas would not have to be filled with program. Instead they could be considered light wells or thought of as poche space. Maybe the shape of the cones could change slightly to minimize this unusable space.

I also experimented with the idea of using two courtyards because we realized that the shape of our courtyard in our most recent model was not ideal. The courtyard resulted in two larger spaces connected by a narrow space.

Monday, November 16, 2009

Mid-Review Critique






During our mid-semester review on Thursday, we received a lot of constructive criticism for our building design. A few of the comments we thought were important were:
- sometimes the geometry works against the fluidity in our building
- the curves need constant moments to register irregularity against.
- the whole form should be thought of as terracing or stepping back (including the south facade)
- the circulation should be further developed because it takes up too much space
Our reviewers saw potential in our cone model. Danielle and I agreed that our project has lost something from our cone model so we compared the two in order to help us decide what aspects would be important to keep and what to change.
We like the cone model because:
-the cone model has regular, predictable curves (cones) in contrast to dramatic, irregular curves (connect curve)
- the courtyard in the cone model is equally important to shaping the building as the classroom cones
- there is more variation in section in the cone model
Possibilities for our current model:
- the terraces could be wider and become occupied
- all of the terraces could lean back toward the north for sunlight
- differences in classroom heights could exaggerate the height difference of the four towers
- the classrooms could touch in the center to create two courtyards (this would allow us to shape the courtyards more like inverted cones)

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Plans in Progress

Level 5

Level 4

Level 3


Level 2


Level 1


Level 0


Level -1

Wednesday, October 28, 2009




During our desk crit yesterday, we discussed the results of the "c" shaped forms we created. Curving the classrooms not only provides more sunlight and allows for terracing, it also creates two outdoor conditions; a private courtyard and a public one. Each classroom has access to the central courtyard for the whole school. The classrooms also have access to private courtyards on the interior of the cones.


Another topic we discussed was how the circulation might be located relative to the classrooms. For this model, I tried to come up with a circulation pattern that would connect clasrooms on the same floor since the grades would be organized by floor level. I also placed the circulation on the side of the classrooms that would get less sunlight.